Whole roof + new wood.Approved for the deductible.$12,000+ kept
$80K+kept by 5 homeowners in 6 weeksMay–June 2026
Real Savings, Real Homeowners
Insurance Paid. Homeowners Kept The Difference.
Five recent homeowners, five roofs approved through insurance. Together they kept over $80,000 out of their own pockets. Tap any job to see the photos.
Combined out-of-pocket savings$80K+across 5 insurance-approved roofs, May to June 2026
Free inspection, no obligation. Every policy is different and coverage is decided by your carrier; we make sure the claim is documented and presented the right way.
I had a great experience with First Response Roofing from start to finish. Sy walked me through the entire process and worked with the insurance company. The roof was completed in one day and looks great. Highly recommend.
B
Boyer Brothers PaintingOne-day install · September 2026
★★★★★
We worked with Sy and his crew on a home in Dublin. They did the roof for a renovation project we were on. They were very fast and organized. Full roof replacement in one day! Highly recommend and we will be referring them to all our customers in the future with confidence!
L
Leslie H.Roof replacement · May 2026
★★★★★
Jay and the roofing crew did a fantastic job replacing my roof. They were quick, knowledgeable, respectful and they cleaned up the debris so well. The communication with the company was awesome. I will hire them for more projects that I need done. Thank you Sy for your direction and kindness.
J
Jessica T.Roof replacement · May 2026
★★★★★
First Response Roofing absolutely knocked it out of the park. From the first phone call to the final cleanup, the entire process was professional, fast, and stress-free. The crew showed up on time, worked hard, and treated my property with respect the whole way through. The quality of the work speaks for itself. They were honest, upfront, and kept me informed every step of the way, which is hard to find these days.
H
Huong T.Insurance claim · June 2026
★★★★★
I love this amazing team. Sy is a great mentor for his employees, doing extremely good work. You won’t be disappointed with the insurance quoted with First Response Roofing.
D
Danny B.Roof & gutters · May 2026
★★★★★
Very professional experience. These guys made it easy to get my roof and gutters. From start to finish I had solid people to deal with. Roof looks great, couldn’t be happier with the work.
D
David A.Roofing · August 2026
★★★★★
Knowing how much effort and care goes into everything they do, you really couldn’t be in better hands. Honest, reliable, and deeply dedicated to quality. Highly recommend!
Local, independent, and on your roof in person. The project manager who inspects it sees your claim through.
Owner
Sy
Walks every homeowner through the claim himself.
“Sy walked me through the entire process and worked with the insurance company.”
Ryan M., Google review
Project Manager
Jeremy
Goes to bat with your carrier. Saved one homeowner $20,000+.
“Big shoutout to our project manager Jeremy for going to bat for another homeowner.”
First Response Roofing, May 2026
Project Manager
Laura
Guides homeowners from inspection to approval.
“Great work, Laura. Keep making a difference one homeowner at a time.”
First Response Roofing, July 2026
Newest Team Member
Natalie
Trained in the field the First Response way.
Trained In The Field
Anyone Can Climb A Roof. We Train To Get It Right.
Proper training is what separates a good roofing company from a great one. Our crew trains together on real roofs: how to document damage correctly, what insurance is actually looking for, and when a repair is the more honest answer than a replacement.
01
Document it correctly
Every point of damage photographed and written up the way an adjuster needs to see it.
02
Know what insurance looks for
The crew is trained on what carriers actually cover, so real damage does not get missed.
03
Repair when repair is right
If a repair is the smarter, more honest answer, that is what you hear. Not the most profitable one.
“Protecting our customers means giving them the right solution, not just the easiest or most profitable one.”First Response Roofing, March 2026
Sy, owner of First Response Roofing
Straight Talk From The Owner
5 Red Flags When Hiring A Roofer.
Before you let anyone on your roof, Sy says to check these. He is honest that First Response is a new company, and he would rather you ask the hard questions.
!
No insurance
If they are not insured and something gets damaged, nothing covers it.
!
No permits
If they cannot pull a permit, chances are they are not licensed.
!
High-pressure sales
A good roofer gives you time to decide.
!
Wanting the full amount down
Be wary of anyone who asks for everything upfront.
!
Time in business
Ask how long they have been around and whether they will be there if there is an issue.
Read the video transcript
Sy here with First Response Roofing, and today I want to talk about some red flags to look for when hiring a roofing contractor. First and foremost, insurance. If they don’t have insurance, that’s a big problem. If anything happens, if anything gets damaged, they don’t have the insurance to cover it. Second thing would be permits. If they can’t get a permit, chances are they’re probably not licensed. Those are two major things to look for. Others are high-pressure sales tactics and wanting the full amount down. And if the company has only been in business for a few months, such as myself, that is a tough thing as a new business owner, but that is the reality of it. If you haven’t been in business for a while, it’s a scary decision to make, because who knows if these guys are going to be around if there is an issue. So those are some major red flags to look for when hiring a contractor.
Still wondering about something? Call or text (614) 975-1111, or book a free inspection and ask us on the roof.
Will my insurance cover a new roof?
It depends on your policy and on whether the damage came from a covered event such as wind or hail. We inspect and photograph the damage for free, tell you honestly whether it is worth filing, and if you file we work with your carrier on the claim. When a claim is approved, homeowners are typically responsible for their deductible.
How much can insurance save me?
It depends on the damage and your policy. Five recent homeowners we worked with kept between $12,000 and $21,000+ out of pocket when their roofs were approved through insurance.
Should I call my insurance company or a roofer first?
Many homeowners start with a free roof inspection so they know whether there is real, covered damage before they contact their carrier. We document the damage and tell you honestly whether it is worth filing.
Another roofer said my roof was fine. Should I get a second look?
Yes. Damage is hard to see from the ground and easy to miss from a ladder. We have found real, claimable damage on roofs other contractors passed on, including one homeowner who saved over $14,000 after three other contractors could not get it done.
Will filing a claim raise my premium?
That depends on your carrier and your policy, so it is a good question for your insurance agent. What we can tell you is whether the damage is significant enough to be worth filing in the first place.
What should I do after a storm damages my roof?
Stay safe and off the roof, take photos from the ground, and book a free inspection before making permanent repairs. We document the damage the same visit and explain what your carrier will need.
How quickly can a roof replacement be completed?
Most full replacements are finished in one day, which homeowners mention again and again in their reviews. Weather and roof size can extend that, and you get a clear schedule before work begins.
What warranty comes with a new roof?
Full replacements come with a Limited Lifetime Warranty on materials and our 10-Year Craftsmanship Warranty on the installation.
Are you licensed and insured?
Yes. First Response Roofing is licensed, bonded and insured, an IKO RoofPro contractor, an Owens Corning partner, and BBB accredited with an A− rating.
Which areas do you serve?
First Response Roofing serves Pickerington, Canal Winchester, Reynoldsburg, Pataskala, Blacklick, Etna, Baltimore, Groveport, Whitehall, Bexley and communities across greater Columbus.
Service Area
Local To Pickerington. Ready Across East Columbus.
A local crew, not a national call center. Tap your town to see it on the map.
Pick what's going on, choose a day and a window, and we'll call to confirm. If insurance can cover it, we will tell you, and we will work the claim with you.
5.0
